Why gold is a hedge for almost all seasons

By Bob Iaccino

At a glance

• The performance of gold can vary significantly based on economic, geopolitical and market factors
• Historically, gold performs well when interest rates are falling as investors look for safe assets

Gold has long been considered a safe-haven asset, with investors turning to the precious metal during times of economic uncertainty. However, its performance may vary significantly depending on prevailing economic conditions. Given that the Fed’s next move will be to cut interest rates, how has gold historically performed under various combinations of falling or stable interest rates, economic growth and inflation?

1. Falling interest rates, falling economy and falling inflation (soft-Landing)

Gold has often underperformed during periods of falling interest rates, a slower economy and falling inflation. A first example occurred in the early 2000s, specifically from 2001 to 2003.

The US economy slowed significantly after the bursting of the dot-com bubble and the 9/11 attacks. The Federal Reserve responded by cutting interest rates aggressively, from 6.5% in January 2001 to 1% by June 2003. Inflation declined during this period, falling from 3.4% in 2000 to 1.6% in 2002.

Gold’s performance during this time has been generally positive, though not spectacular. The price of gold rose from about $270 an ounce in early 2001 to about $350 an ounce by the end of 2003, representing a gain of about 30% in three years.

Gold’s relatively modest performance during this period can be attributed to several factors. While lower interest rates typically support gold prices by reducing the opportunity cost of holding the non-yielding asset, the deflationary environment and slower economic growth have created conflicting pressures.

Looking at the Fed’s September decision and beyond, a hybrid scenario where inflation is contained without triggering a recession – involving gradual rate cuts and steady growth – could still support gold prices through a mix of inflation concerns and accommodative policy. This could make gold an effective hedge in the coming months.

At the end of Q2 2024, Micro Gold futures were already trading 27% higher YTD at 93,000 contracts per day on average, mainly due to market price volatility. The latest data from August shows Micro Gold ADV futures up 170% from August 2023 to 124,000 contracts.

2. Rapidly falling interest rates, rapidly slowing the economy and falling inflation

Periods of rapidly falling interest rates, a rapid economic slowdown and falling inflation have typically been positive for gold as investors seek safe-haven assets. A prime example occurred during the 2008 global financial crisis.

In response to the crisis, the Federal Reserve cut interest rates from 5.25% in September 2007 to effectively zero by December 2008. The US economy contracted sharply, with real GDP falling 2.5% in 2009. Also inflation declined, falling from 3.8% in 2008 to -0.4% in 2009.

Gold has performed exceptionally during this period of economic turmoil. The price of gold rose from around $700 per ounce in late 2007 to over $1,000 per ounce in early 2009 and continued to rise in the following years, reaching a peak of nearly $1,900 per ounce in 2011.

Gold’s strong performance in this crisis can be attributed to its status as a safe-haven asset. As the financial system teetered on the brink of collapse and traditional assets such as stocks and real estate fell in value, investors sought the perceived safety of gold. While the economy remains relatively stable in early September, any sign of a more severe recession could prompt more aggressive Fed action and underscore gold’s role as a safe haven.

3. Falling interest rates, stable economy and rising inflation

The period 2003-2006 provides another interesting case study. The US economy was relatively stable during this period, with GDP growth averaging about 3% annually. Inflation rose moderately, rising from 1.6% in 2002 to 3.2% by 2006. The Federal Reserve, which had kept interest rates low in the early 2000s, began a gradual tightening cycle in 2004, but maintained a generally accommodating attitude.

Gold prices performed strongly during this period, rising from about $350 per ounce in early 2003 to over $700 per ounce by mid-2006, representing a roughly 100% gain in just over three years.

Gold’s positive performance during this time can be attributed to a combination of factors. Rising inflation created a demand for gold as a hedge against inflation, and as interest rates rose only gradually, the opportunity cost of holding gold remained relatively low. Since early September, the Fed has been signaling potential rate cuts, while inflation remains above target. This environment could benefit from gold, retracing the 2003-2006 period.

Models are not predictive

Historical examples demonstrate that the performance of gold as an asset can vary significantly depending on prevailing economic conditions. However, some general patterns emerge:

• Gold tends to perform well during periods of economic uncertainty, mainly when interest rates are falling and investors are looking for safe-haven assets.
• Rising inflation, especially when combined with low or falling interest rates, creates a particularly favorable environment for gold prices.
• In deflationary environments, gold may underperform, but it can still appeal to investors looking for a store of value during economic downturns.
• Steady economic growth can provide a favorable backdrop for gold investment, particularly when combined with accommodative monetary policy and rising inflationary expectations.

It is important to note that while these historical patterns can provide insight, the gold market is influenced by a complex interplay of economic, geopolitical and market factors, and its behavior can sometimes deviate from historical norms. As the Fed continues to assess and adjust US monetary policy, gold will be an area to monitor for many market participants.

Original post

Editor’s note: The abstracts for this article were chosen by the editors of Seeking Alpha.